I paid little mind to the school lunch deficit controversy raging at Albuquerque Public schools until I saw a bunch of kids dressed as cheese sandwiches protesting outside a school board meeting.
It was an attention-getting device, to be sure. Those cute little cheese sandwiches were a good visual, I thought, a clever way for “anti-hunger activists” to dramatize their point that some New Mexicans cannot afford to pay for school lunches for their kids.
The costumes were apt because, in an effort to prompt some parents to pay and close a $140,000 deficit, APS had announced it would begin serving a cold cheese sandwich, carton of milk and piece of fruit to students who were behind on their lunch tabs.
But some people, it turned out, said they were there that night to protest the school district’s decision to serve lowly cheese sandwiches, which they thought weren’t nutritious enough and might be humiliating for students to receive.
Then, when I heard how the entire issue was being framed by many in the media, I got mad.
Those cheese sandwiches — the real ones, not the dressed-up kids — somehow managed to get in the way getting in the way of the real debate we should be having.
You know, the one about the growing ranks of families in New Mexico who truly can’t afford the lunch tab.
Instead, the issue became a rage-fest about so-called deadbeat parents who are too lazy to pack their kids a lunch and too cheap to pay for a school-issued one.
And how dare some poor kids and their parents get mad about having to eat a cheese sandwich, I heard one particularly rabid radio host say. They should be lucky they’re getting anything for free!
The debate about cheese sandwiches was an unfortunate distraction from the fact that many parents in this profoundly poor state truly cannot afford to pay. And it’s a diversion from the fact that even when those parents fill out the paperwork to get the free federal lunch assistance for which they qualify, APS policies make it hard for their kids to actually collect a hot meal.
I don’t work with families who can’t afford lunches, but I have a friend who works at a nonprofit advocacy agency and she does it every single day.
I happened to run into her this week, and she shared her anger at how cheese sandwiches managed to hijack the debate about hunger in New Mexico.
She’s a writer herself, and she shared with a me a letter (yes, people do still write those!) that she’d written about her experience with the issue.
“This is not about dueling scapegoats: cheese and deadbeats,” she wrote. “It’s about a short-sighted strategy employed by a beleaguered school administration to solve a long-standing and worsening problem –- poverty as it manifests in the school lunch line.”
APS typically carries a deficit in the school lunch program and has employed many different strategies over the years to increase enrollment in the federal free lunch program, with varying degrees of success, she told me.
“Some of the problems of APS’ administrative approach can be illustrated by just one family’s experiences. A single mother of two applied exactly three times this school year –– at each of the schools her children attended, such transience not at all uncommon in districts and, particularly in the Southeast Heights, where wholly a third half of students change schools with a school year.
“This parent was never notified by schools #2 or #3 about whether she had qualified. She checked a few times, meanwhile believing her children were qualified as they had been at school #1 — only to learn from her children after several days that one was being denied her lunch while the other was not — an inexplicable contradiction/discrepancy.
The one being given the cheese sandwich happened to be the one of her children allergic to cheese — as are many Native Americans, lactose intolerant — a fact alone that should have prompted the district in the nation’s largest Native American population to rethink its alternative food choices. Never mind that this extremely responsible mother had already notified the school of her child’s food allergy.”
My friend said her agency and others who work with the poor have offered many ideas for improving lunch delivery and easing the APS lunch deficit, including cutting costs by centralizing food preparation, or lowering the threshold for designating a school for school-wide free lunch, thereby eliminating the need for a cashier and staff time to collect payments and process collections.
“The board, elected by us, should ask many more questions of its well-paid administration before buying into the idea that squeezing a few thousand dollars from struggling parents will solve this long-standing problem any more than processed cheese will solve the problem of hunger.”
I guess that’s true. But it’s way easier just to talk about cheese sandwiches.